Skip to content

Guild name vote (closed)

The vote is closed. The guild is The True Torchmen. Pass The Torch stays as the name of the Discord server and of this site. This page is the record: the result, how the vote ran, and the rules it ran under.

When Step
September 24 Round 1 opened in the launch-plan channel. Nominations ran 5 days, one name per Discord account
September 29 Voting opened. Approval voting, 4 days, counts hidden until the close
October 3 The round closed with a clear winner. No tie, so no runoff
October 7 The rank names were set and the proclamation went up

The turnout was small. That is recorded here as it happened. The goal was a name the guild is still proud of in 2028, and the failure modes were known: a joke that wins on a laugh, a name nobody hates but nobody loves, a process that feels rigged, and a name that turns out to be taken on launch night. The process below was built against all four.

The vote ran on the guild’s own bot. The board was a single message in the launch-plan channel with buttons, and everything a member did on it was private. Everyone with the WoW Forever role could take part. One nomination and one ballot per Discord account.

  • A member hit Submit or change my name on the board and typed one name. It could be changed or withdrawn until nominations closed.
  • Names had to be 2 to 24 characters, letters and spaces only. That is WoW’s rule. vanilla baseline
  • Duplicate names merged. The board listed names in random order with the nominators hidden.
  • Officers could remove a name only for breaking Blizzard’s naming rules, for being a current meme, or for punning on the game’s own terms, and had to post the reason. Never for taste. No name was removed by an officer in this vote.
  • The board switched to voting on its own when nominations closed.
  • Approval voting: members picked every name they could live with, up to the limit for the round. No ranking.
  • Counts stayed hidden until the close, so nobody could bandwagon.
  • At the close the bot posted and pinned the results with full counts. Showing the counts was the anti-rigging measure.
  • A tie at the top would have gone to a 48-hour runoff. There was no tie.
  • The runner-up was recorded as the backup name for launch night in case the winner is taken or blocked. No re-vote if that happens.

Approval voting surfaces consensus candidates rather than polarizing ones: voters tick every name they would be happy with, and joke names that half the guild loves and half hates lose to names most people can live with. verified Its known weakness is bullet voting, where people tick only their favorite; in one seven-candidate approval election about 60 percent of voters picked just one. verified

Guild names that stick are short, rhythmic, say the group’s character before anyone meets them, and are not tied to a moment. verified This was the checklist for nominations, and it is the checklist for the motto and the tabard that come next:

  1. Two to three words, under 20 characters if you can. It has to read in a tabard tooltip and in “Name is recruiting.”
  2. Says the vibe. Someone reading only the name should guess “friends, semi-serious, not sweaty.”
  3. Not a current meme. A 2026 joke is a 2028 embarrassment. The two-year test: will the 40-year-old version of you wear it?
  4. Not a pun on the game’s own terms (Forever, Classic Plus). Those date instantly and Blizzard’s filter may flag them.
  5. Pronounceable in voice. People will say it out loud a thousand times.
  6. Searchable. Not a common English word, not something that collides with a big streamer guild.
  7. Works as a ritual word. “For the Torchmen” and “Torchmen night” should not sound stupid.

And the process rules:

  • The joke energy has a home. Tabard, motto, pod names, and titles can all be funny. The guild name is the one thing that has to survive being said in a job interview.
  • The GM had one veto, usable only against a name that would embarrass members outside the game, stated publicly with the reason.
  • The name is locked for at least two seasons. Guilds that rename throw away the identity investment they just built. verified
When Step
Next Motto vote, then the tabard design contest. See Contests and events
Oct 27 to Nov 3 Name reservation window. Reserve your character names. Guild-name reservation has not been announced, so the backup name matters unverified
Nov 4, 6:00 PM Eastern Launch. OPB founds the guild as The True Torchmen. If the name is blocked, the backup is used, no re-vote. See Road to launch

Officers ran the vote with !guildname (alias !names). Members only ever needed the buttons.

Command What it did
!guildname status Phase, close time, how many nominated and voted. Anyone could run it
!guildname open [nomHours] [voteHours] [maxPicks] Opened a round. Round 1 was opened with 120 and 96 hours (5 and 4 days)
!guildname vote / close / extend <hours> Moved or ended the current phase
!guildname remove <name> Removed a nomination that broke the rules, with the reason posted in the channel
!guildname results Showed the tally. During voting it only worked inside officer channels
!guildname runoff <N> [hours] Would have opened a runoff among the top N after a tie
  • Whether Forever supports guild-name reservation during the Oct 27 window. Nothing announced, so the backup name stays on file.
  • Whether Forever’s guild-name limit is the vanilla 24 characters, letters and spaces.
  • Forever’s charter cost and signature count at launch. See Guild charter.

Next: the guild the vote named, on The True Torchmen.