Skip to content

Below level 40, higher level trade goods move far more gold a day, and nearly all of them sell

We asked which single trade goods below level 40 are worth the most in each level band, and whether they actually sell. Most of us spend our first weeks at launch in exactly these levels, so it helps to know which materials are worth listing and which just sit there.

Split the trade goods below level 40 into four bands by item level: levels 1 to 9 (the lowest band), the teens (10 to 19), the twenties (20 to 29) and the thirties (30 to 39). Trade goods are the materials: cloth, leather, herbs, ore, stone, meat, dust and the like. For each band, which single item has the highest price, and how many of it sell in a day?

A useful answer names the dearest item in each band, says whether it really sells or only has a high asking price, and shows how much gold each band moves as a whole.

  • Copper traded a day climbs with item level. On PvP Horde, trade goods in the thirties change hands for about 9368g 29s 26c a day, against 712g 84s 84c in the lowest band. PvP Alliance shows the same order: 7300g 35s 31c against 593g 82s 75c.
  • The dearest single trade good per band on PvP Horde: Large Glowing Shard at 6g in the thirties (about 53 sold a day), Cerulean Dye at 5g 40s 95c in the twenties (about 103 a day) and Small Lustrous Pearl at 63s in the teens (about 375 a day). The Shard also leads its band on PvP Alliance, at 16g 55s.
  • Almost everything sells: by the estimate, 91.5% of these trade goods on PvP Horde and 93.4% on PvP Alliance sell ten or more a day. The exception is the lowest band, where the dearest item on PvP Horde, Red Whelp Scale at 65s, sells only about 4 a day.

We used one thing only: the newest complete scan on each PvP market. That is the PvP Horde scan of 20 October at 12:31 UTC and the PvP Alliance scan of 20 October at 13:38 UTC. Only these full scans carry a sold-a-day figure, so the older daily history plays no part here.

We kept trade goods only, and banded them by item level. Item level is the level the game gives the item itself, not the level you need to use it. A level 35 material can be gathered or looted by a level 30 character, which is why the thirties band has items even with the level 30 cap. We left out gear, recipes and potions: gear prices depend on stats and random bonuses, so one piece of armor is not a fair match for a stack of herbs.

For each item we read three numbers from the scan: the median price (the middle asking price), the number listed, and the estimated number sold a day. “Copper traded a day” for a band is each item’s median price times its sold-a-day estimate, added up across the band. We call an item busy when it sells ten or more a day. We picked ten because below that a single player listing or clearing out a few can swing the estimate.

The full picture, by our own reading of the same scans. Dearest item first, then the item that moves the most copper a day in that band:

Band Market Dearest item Median Listed Sold a day Most copper a day
1 to 9 Horde Red Whelp Scale 65s 50 about 4 Rough Stone, 1s 99c, about 8,164 a day
1 to 9 Alliance Green Whelp Scale 1g 95s 1 about 16 Perfect Deviate Scale, 95s, about 104 a day
10 to 19 Horde Small Lustrous Pearl 63s 363 about 375 Briarthorn, 33s, about 1,764 a day
10 to 19 Alliance Small Lustrous Pearl 84s 98c 59 about 569 Small Lustrous Pearl
20 to 29 Horde Cerulean Dye 5g 40s 95c 61 about 103 Kingsblood, 30s 85c, about 1,872 a day
20 to 29 Alliance Elemental Earth 15g 7s 4 about 14 Cerulean Dye, 4g 88s 99c, about 126 a day
30 to 39 Horde Large Glowing Shard 6g 32 about 53 Goldthorn, 3g 6s, about 532 a day
30 to 39 Alliance Large Glowing Shard 16g 55s 36 about 64 Solid Stone, 1g 55s, about 755 a day

Two things stand out. In the teens and the thirties, both markets agree on the dearest item. In the lowest band and the twenties they do not, and the leader on one side has only 1 or 4 listed. A price with that few listings is one seller’s asking price, not a market. Elemental Earth on PvP Alliance is a good example: its 7 day median is 7g 27s 77c, about half of today’s figure.

Some prices in this single scan also sit far from their own 7 day median. Heavy Grinding Stone on PvP Horde shows 1g 99s against a 7 day median of about 16s 73c, and Goldthorn shows 3g 6s against about 90s 77c. That is why we do not treat any one price here as settled.

Cerulean Dye is new to Forever, so it has no history from the original game to compare with. You can look up any of these items on The Terminal, and Sell or vendor shows when the vendor pays more than the auction house.

Bar chart of copper traded a day in each item level band on both PvP markets, rising from about 712g and 593g in the lowest band to about 9,368g and 7,300g in the thirties

Each bar is one band on one market. Red is PvP Horde, blue is PvP Alliance. Every step up in level moves more gold a day than the step below it, on both markets. Horde is busier than Alliance in every band.

Scatter chart of price against units sold a day for 210 PvP Horde trade goods below level 40, with the dearest items selling tens to hundreds a day and the cheapest cloth and stone selling thousands

Each dot is one trade good on PvP Horde. Higher means dearer, further right means more sold a day. The dots slope down to the right: the dear items sell in the tens or hundreds, while cheap cloth, stone and dust sell in the thousands. The few dots far to the left are the items that barely sell at all.

Scatter chart of herb prices against units sold a day on PvP Horde, with Goldthorn the herb that moves the most gold a day

Herbs only, every level, on PvP Horde. Goldthorn sits up and to the right: dear and busy at once. Black Lotus and Arthas’ Tears are dearer, but they are higher level herbs that barely sell in the beta, so they are outside this question.

  • More full scans. The sold-a-day figure comes from one day of scans. If a week of later scans showed the thirties band moving less copper a day than the twenties on either market, the first bullet would be wrong.
  • A steadier leader. If the dearest item in a band changes from scan to scan, as it already differs between factions in the lowest band and the twenties, then “the dearest item” there is noise, and only the band totals mean anything. We would want the same leader on most days of a week before naming it with confidence.
  • Large Glowing Shard falling behind. If later scans show the Shard below Goldthorn or Cerulean Dye on most days, the second bullet no longer holds.
  • Busy share dropping. If the share of trade goods selling ten or more a day fell below about three in four on later scans, the third bullet would no longer hold.
  • Level 30 cap, no raids. Most of the demand for materials at launch comes from leveling crafters and later from raid consumables. In the beta, the thirties band is the top of what anyone can use, which may push its prices up. At launch, players level past it, and its share of the trade may change.
  • Small population. A few players can set the price of a rare item. Several of the dearest items here have fewer than 40 listed, and two have 4 or fewer.
  • The wipe. Everything is deleted before launch on November 4. Nothing here is a reason to hold anything. What may carry over is the order: higher level materials moving more gold, and rare drops being dear but slow.
  • One scan, not history. This report uses only the newest scan on each market. Older days in our history come from AHledger’s daily history, which has no sold-a-day figure, so we cannot say if these numbers are typical or a one-day spike.
  • Estimates. Sold a day is an estimate, not a count of real sales, and it exists only for the newest scan. Read the order, not the size.
  • What this cannot tell you: how often anything drops, how fast anyone earns, or which item is best to farm. The data shows prices and sales, not how long it takes to get anything.