Loot rules
An unfair loot system breaks even the most fun guild. Loot is a top-three cited cause of churn in guild post-mortems, behind leadership failure and burnout rather than ahead of them: in the thread this page used to cite for the opposite claim, loot is named in 1 of 9 comments while leadership is named in 7. verified The line “an unfair loot system can break even the most fun of guilds” is one commenter there, not a finding. What every source from 2009 to now does agree on is that a council is distrusted when members cannot reconstruct how a decision was reached, which is why the published-reasoning rule below exists. verified So the rules are written before the first raid, published here, and never changed mid-tier. This is version 1. The short charter’s line 3 is the summary; this page is the whole thing. The reasoning behind each system, and the addon fallback stack, is on Loot systems.
System 1: soft reserve (10 and 20 player raids, until a core forms)
Section titled “System 1: soft reserve (10 and 20 player raids, until a core forms)”This is the friends-scale system for Barrow Deeps (10) and Hyjal Summit (20) while the roster is still forming. DKP and EPGP are overkill under roughly 25 raiders. verified
Soft reserve (SR). Before the raid, each raider names one item they want from that raid. Declare it in the raid signup thread by the deadline (24 hours before start; 6 hours is the absolute floor). The list is locked before the first pull and cannot be changed once the raid has started. The documented abuse is re-reserving something else after your pick fails to drop, which quietly hands you a second reserve. When your reserved item drops, you roll only against the other people who reserved it. If you are the only person who reserved it, it is yours with no roll. If nobody reserved it, it goes to open rolls.
Main spec over off spec (MS>OS). On open rolls, everyone who needs the item for the spec they raid as rolls first. Off-spec rolls happen only if no main-spec roll is made. Your main spec is what your character sheet says (!sheet), and you tell the raid leader before the raid if it changes.
One item per run, and +1. One contested item per run. When you win a contested roll, you are +1 for the rest of that run: anyone at 0 beats you on the next contested roll, and you only take a second item if nobody at 0 needs it. Uncontested drops (nobody else rolls) do not count against you. The +1 resets every run.
Rolls. /roll (1 to 100), highest wins, ties re-roll. The loot master or raid leader calls “SR roll for X” or “MS roll for X” in voice, waits ten seconds, awards.
Off-spec definition, Forever-specific. Forever changed healing and damage stat conversion, so a healer’s +healing piece is still main spec for healers, and a caster DPS piece is main spec for casters, not “off spec” for a healer because it gives some healing. verified Hybrid classes declare one raid spec.
Hard reserve (HR). Items the guild takes off the table before anyone reserves: crafting essences and anything the bank needs for progression consumables. The hard reserve list is published in the same signup thread as the soft reserves, before invites go out. An undisclosed hard reserve is the single most cited grievance about soft reserve anywhere, because it looks exactly like a declared system being overridden after the fact. If it is not on the list before the raid, it is not hard reserved.
Shared armour and hybrid items. Where one item is main spec for two roles, the tank or healer has priority over a damage spec, and the raid leader says so before the pull. This is the best-documented way main spec over off spec goes wrong in Classic: plate and mail drops bleed to damage specs on equal rolls, tanks and healers stop gearing, and then the guild cannot field a tank. verified
BoE epics from the raid go to the bank alt to fund progression consumables. See Guild bank.
System 2: loot council (once a core forms, or any 40)
Section titled “System 2: loot council (once a core forms, or any 40)”Council starts when either of these happens, whichever first:
- A core roster of 20 has cleared Hyjal Summit twice under soft reserve and wants the switch, or
- The guild hosts a 40 player Onyxia raid. If we join someone else’s 40, their rules apply.
The switch is announced at least two lockouts ahead, takes effect at a reset, and never applies to loot already awarded. Hyjal’s 13 bosses, nine-class tier, and crafting essences make rolls waste a long instance, which is why the council exists at 20. verified
Council mechanics
Section titled “Council mechanics”- Council of 3 to 5: the loot officer, the raid leader, and at least one non-officer rotated monthly, so the council is visibly broader than the friend group. verified
- Decide inside 60 seconds on farm, 3 minutes on progression. If it takes longer, the rubric is missing a row.
- Council members abstain on items they themselves want, including when they want it for another character.
- Minimum three non-abstaining scorers. An officer backfills an abstaining seat so the council never shrinks below three. If it still cannot resolve, it falls to the loot officer, then the raid leader, then the GM, in that order. With three seats and mandatory abstention a contested tier token can otherwise end up decided by one person, which is the opaque-deliberation failure wearing a rubric. verified
- Candidates pre-declare before the council talks: best in slot, main-spec upgrade, off spec, or pass, with one line of why. Real councils resolve most items in about ninety seconds because of this step, and it gives the upgrade-size row an auditable input instead of a guess.
- No arguing loot during the raid. Take it to the loot officer after the lockout. The 48 hour appeal below covers the aftermath, not the pull timer.
- One player cannot take two pieces off one boss unless the second is uncontested. verified
- Every award is posted in the raid channels in Discord with the two highest totals. Those channels are added when raids unlock; see the Discord guide.
- Appeals: DM the GM within 48 hours. The GM reverses only for a rubric error, never for taste. The 48 hours is the loot window; the 7 days in the charter covers removals and conduct.
The rubric
Section titled “The rubric”Scores are 0 to 3 per row, multiplied by the weight, summed. Highest total wins. Ties go to fewest items this tier, then a /roll. The numbers are ours; the structure (attendance, upgrade size, tier completion, role priority) is what the research recommends. verified
| Criterion | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Upgrade size (main spec) | Sidegrade | Minor | Solid | Best in slot, or replaces a green or blue | x3 |
| Attendance, rolling 4 weeks | Under 50% | 50 to 74% | 75 to 89% | 90%+ or benched-available | x2 |
| Preparation (consumables, attunement, enchants on time) | Repeatedly missing | Sometimes | Usually | Always | x1 |
| Loot received this tier (main spec) | 3+ items | 2 | 1 | 0 | x2 |
| Role impact for the raid | Cosmetic for the raid | Small | Meaningful (a healer’s mana, a tank’s health) | Progression-blocking piece | x2 |
| Rank | Trial | Member | Raider | No bonus above Raider | x1 |
Tier set pieces have one extra rule: the fourth piece matters more than the second, so a player completing a four-piece bonus scores upgrade 3 even if the single item is a small stat gain. What each set gives at each piece count is on Tier sets.
Worked example
Section titled “Worked example”A tank chest drops in Hyjal Summit. Two tanks want it.
| Row | Tank A | Tank B |
|---|---|---|
| Upgrade | 3 x3 = 9 (replaces a blue) | 2 x3 = 6 (solid) |
| Attendance | 3 x2 = 6 (92%) | 3 x2 = 6 (95%) |
| Preparation | 3 x1 = 3 | 2 x1 = 2 |
| Loot this tier | 2 x2 = 4 (one item so far) | 3 x2 = 6 (nothing yet) |
| Role impact | 3 x2 = 6 | 3 x2 = 6 |
| Rank | 2 x1 = 2 (Raider) | 2 x1 = 2 (Raider) |
| Total | 30 | 28 |
Tank A gets the chest. Tank B is first in line next time, and the loot-history post shows both totals so everyone can see why. That last part is the whole point.
The essence rule
Section titled “The essence rule”Forever’s Hyjal crafted epics need Malleable Essence of Nature, a reagent acquired by disenchanting items from Hyjal Summit or Barrow Deeps. About 72 patterns use it, all sold by a vendor in Mount Hyjal, across Tailoring, Leatherworking, and Blacksmithing sets. verified (datamined; class mapping not yet documented) That makes disenchanted raid loot a guild resource, so:
- One designated Enchanter is in every raid.
- Every BoP item nobody needs is disenchanted and the essence goes to the bank alt, logged on the ledger.
- Crafted essence pieces are assigned exactly like drops: by SR rules while we run SR, by the council rubric once council starts.
- The crafter keeps any bonus procs; the guild covers vendor costs. See Guild bank and Professions.
Rules that apply to both systems
Section titled “Rules that apply to both systems”- Trials are behind members on contested main-spec items for the trial period only, equal on uncontested. The end date is stated when the trial starts. See Recruitment and trials.
- Mains before alts. Alts roll only if no main needs. Alt raids only after the main roster has cleared the content twice.
- Legendary questline items: the first recipient is named in advance, at a monthly meeting, once the item is known.
- Pug loot: if we bring a pug to fill, they roll under our rules, told before the first pull. Ninja-looting in pugs while wearing the tabard is a ladder-removal offense per the charter.
- Nothing changes mid-tier. A rule change is proposed at a monthly meeting, announced two lockouts ahead, and starts at a reset.
Transparency
Section titled “Transparency”- Every award, under either system, is posted in the raid channels in Discord: item, winner, and the reason (SR roll result or the two highest rubric totals).
- Loot history is exported from whatever tool we use, or kept by hand in the sheet if the addons lag. Gargul imports soft reserves and exports awards; RCLootCouncil has a loot history log. Neither had a Forever build in September. Gargul listed a Forever file, v8.0.1-forever, on October 3 (CurseForge API check, 2026-10-04); that is the author’s claim, not a guild test. RCLootCouncil published its first Forever file, 3.26.0-beta.1-forever, on November 19 (CurseForge API check, 2026-11-19): a beta build, and also untested by the guild. verified The rubric works in a spreadsheet.
- Appeals and reversals are logged too.
The GDKP ban
Section titled “The GDKP ban”Blizzard banned GDKP (gold DKP: loot auctioned for gold, pot split among the raid) in Forever. The stated reasons: in regions where it ran longest it overtook the traditional guild structure, and it is a barrier to entry for new and poorer players. Gold buying will be “very aggressively” punished, up to permanent account loss. verified The ban covers North America and Europe realms only. Clay Stone told 4Gamers Taiwan it “won’t affect other regions,” per Wowhead on October 9. verified
What that means for us:
- No GDKP under the guild’s name. No gold-for-loot inside the guild. No paid carries advertised in guild channels.
- Do not run or join gold-split pugs on your main. Enforcement inside guilds has not been described anywhere, and one careful source explicitly warns against inventing a penalty ladder. We do not want to find out. verified
- GDKP organizing under the guild’s name is instant removal per the charter.
Unknown as of 2026-11-19
Section titled “Unknown as of 2026-11-19”- Master loot. The client has the answer half way: the group leader’s menu has a Loot Method entry with Master Looter in it, but each method only shows if the server offers it. verified for the menu, game files, build 1.60.1.70338. Details on Loot systems. Not answered at the beta Q&A. The Deep Dive says raid appearances go “only to the player the item binds to, leaving organized loot decisions in the hands of raid groups,” which is suggestive, not explicit. If master loot is gone, both systems run on need/greed/pass and trade within the two-hour window, as retail guilds do. The rules above survive either answer. unverified
- Tier priority order per class and role. The class and spec of each of the 18 sets is on Tier sets and set bonuses.
- Whether the Gargul and RCLootCouncil Forever files work in a real raid. Re-check on December 1. See Addons.
- The raid unlock hour on December 9, which sets when these rules go live.
Sources
Section titled “Sources”- https://docs.curseforge.com/rest-api/ (RCLootCouncil Forever file, 3.26.0-beta.1-forever, checked 2026-11-19)
- https://www.wowhead.com/news=383345/gdkp-ban-only-applies-to-na-and-europe-realms-4gamers-interview
- https://guildorder.com/games/wow/guides/loot-systems-dkp-vs-epgp
- https://www.mmo-champion.com/threads/668733-Loot-Council-Rules
- https://us.forums.blizzard.com/en/wow/t/thoughts-on-loot-council-based-off-parsesperformanceattendance-etc/598022
- https://www.mmo-champion.com/threads/1772727-Benching-loot-systems-and-attendance
- https://www.wowhead.com/forever/item=274030/malleable-essence-of-nature
- https://www.pcgamesn.com/world-of-warcraft/forever-buying-gold-rmt-gdkp
- https://wowforeverwiki.org/gdkp
- https://wow-anniversary.fi/en/news/blueposts/wow-forever-qa-gdkp-gold-buying/
- https://worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com/en-us/news/24303313/world-of-warcraft-forever-deep-dive-panel-recap
- Game files, build 1.60.1.70338 (loot method menu)
- https://www.curseforge.com/wow/addons/gargul
- https://www.curseforge.com/wow/addons/rclootcouncil
- https://docs.curseforge.com/rest-api/ (Forever file check, 2026-10-04)
- https://forums.mmorpg.com/discussion/416834/why-do-guilds-die