Guild charter
The short charter pinned in Discord’s start-here channel is seven lines. This page is the long version those seven lines point at. Nothing here contradicts the short version; it explains what each line means when something goes wrong at 11 pm on a raid night. Read it once when you join, and again the first time you are annoyed at someone.
1. Purpose and vibe
Section titled “1. Purpose and vibe”We are The True Torchmen, a friends-and-family guild playing World of Warcraft: Forever. Most of us know each other from outside the game. Many of us are coming back after years away. Expected size is 30 to 80 people, casual to semi-hardcore, on the PvP ruleset and one faction. The guild voted PvP ruleset, 7 to 0, and Horde, 6 to 2 in round 2 (closed October 18, 2026).
The research behind this charter is blunt about why guilds die: from the inside, through absent leaders, loot fights, cliques, and schedule mismatch, far more often than from anything the game does. The guilds that last share one trait: a core of real friends that predates the game. We already have that. The charter’s job is to protect it. verified
Seriousness level, in plain words: we wipe, we laugh, we try again. Nobody gets yelled at. We still prepare, still show up on time, and still want to kill bosses. Effort matters more than hours.
What we are not:
- Not a world-first or race guild. We will not compete with pre-formed private-server veterans in week one, and we do not want to.
- Not a GDKP host, a gold-split raid, or a boosting service. Blizzard has banned GDKP in Forever and has said it will punish gold buying with permanent account loss. verified
- Not a five-nights-a-week guild. Two scheduled raid nights is the ceiling for the core. Everything else is optional and labeled optional.
- Not the parent server. WoW talk stays in the WoW wing, and everything else stays out of it.
2. Ranks and how they are granted
Section titled “2. Ranks and how they are granted”Ranks are permissions. They mirror in-game ranks one to one. Nobody self-assigns, buys, or begs for a rank. The full ladder and the separate titles layer are on Ranks and titles.
| Rank | Who | How it is granted |
|---|---|---|
| WoW Forever | Anyone in the Discord who opts in | Self-serve in onboarding or the wing button. It only means you can see the wing |
| True Torchman (Guild Member) | Everyone in the guild in game | An officer grants it after you join in game and clear the trial (friends: two weeks, show up once; see Recruitment and trials) |
| Torchwarden (Officer) | 2 founding seats: Drunkn, Rambaldi | Founding officers were appointed at the founding; later seats follow the pod-captain season. Term of one year, renewable |
| Flamewarden (Senior Officer) | 3: Yeetyeeters, Hyd3x, ActaFooly | Named by the Guild Master. Second in command, and they stand in when he is away |
| Keeper of the Flame (Guild Master) | 1: OrthodoxPaladinBueller (OPB) | Founds the guild in game on launch night and collects the charter signatures. Owns the charter, the bank ledger, and the final appeal |
| Firebrand / Kindling (Raider / Trial) | Raid core | Added only when raids open. Not before |
| Ember (Alt) | In game only | “Alt of X” in the guild note |
Officer structure as of v1.2: Flamewarden (Senior Officer): 3. Torchwarden (Officer): 2 founding seats. Founding officers were appointed at the founding; later seats follow the pod-captain season. More seats open as the guild grows: message OPB, Yeetyeeters or Hyd3x.
The backup GM is one of the three Flamewardens and will be named in the Officer handbook before launch (see section 9). The backup holds an in-game character with the permissions to take over. If the GM is silent for 30 days with no note, the backup GM takes leadership. This is written down because Forever has not announced any automatic inactive-leader replacement; retail’s 90-day rule may not exist here. unverified
3. Schedule and attendance
Section titled “3. Schedule and attendance”- Show up when you sign up. A signup is a promise to the other nine or nineteen people.
- Absence is a status, not a DM. Post it in the absences channel (or set it in Raid-Helper) before the deadline. The deadline is 24 hours before start when a bench swap is needed, and 2 hours before start at the absolute latest. Absence posted in time is excused, no explanation required.
- Attended means signed up and present within 10 minutes of first pull, or benched and available on Discord for the full window. Bench counts as attendance.
- The bar for Raiders once raids open is 80 percent of scheduled raid nights over a rolling four weeks, with absences posted. Trials are held to 75 percent during their trial. Nobody is counted against a night they excused in time. verified (common guild practice; the exact numbers are ours)
- Real life wins. Kids, work, partners, and sleep come first. Raids end on time. There is no guilt for an absence posted in time, and nobody will ping you asking “are you really going to miss raid?”
- Breaks are normal. Any member can declare a 2 to 4 week break without losing rank. Coming back after longer earns the Returning Hero title, not a walk of shame.
- The engagement calendar (guild night, screenshot Friday, monthly meeting) is on Rituals and calendar. All of it is optional except the monthly meeting for officers.
4. Loot
Section titled “4. Loot”Full rules with the worked rubric are on Loot rules. The charter-level rules:
- Soft reserve, main spec over off spec, one item per run, with +1 tracking, for the 10 and 20 player raids until a core raid team forms.
- Loot council with a written rubric once a core forms or when we host a 40. The rubric is published before the switch and never changed mid-tier.
- Trials are behind members on contested main-spec items for the trial period only. The end date is stated when the trial starts.
- BoE epics from raids go to the bank alt to fund consumables, unless the loot rules for that raid say otherwise.
- Loot history is public. Every award is posted with the reasoning. Councils fail when decisions look arbitrary, not when they are wrong.
- GDKP is banned in Forever. Do not ask. Do not run gold-split pugs on your main either; Blizzard has said it is watching gold flow. verified
5. Bench
Section titled “5. Bench”- Bench is a status, not a punishment. Benched players keep attendance credit.
- The roster, including the bench, is posted 24 hours before the raid. Nobody is surprise-benched.
- Rotation order is published before the tier: on farm, whoever needs nothing from the next boss sits first; on progression, a fixed rotation once the kill comp is locked; never the same person two weeks running unless they ask.
- When we have overflow, the bench runs a second 10 or a dungeon night in the same voice server rather than sitting.
- Performance benching is a private conversation first: what to work on, who will help, when we check again.
6. Alts
Section titled “6. Alts”- Mains first on all contested loot. Alts roll only if no main needs.
- Alts carry “alt of X” in the guild note field.
- Alt raids are scheduled only after the main roster has cleared the same content twice.
- No more than three alts per account in the guild, which the three-character name-reservation limit enforces for us at launch anyway. unverified
- Profession alts are encouraged. List their professions on your character sheet so the roster shows them.
7. Conduct and drama
Section titled “7. Conduct and drama”The short charter says: problem with someone? Talk to them. Still a problem? Talk to an officer. The ladder is on the Officer handbook. The rules behind it:
- Nothing in public channels. Officers enforce this by deleting and DMing, not by public warnings.
- Performance feedback is private and specific. No public parses without the player’s consent, no performance shaming, no “raid or leave” pressure on family members.
- Voice etiquette is pinned and short: push-to-talk during pulls, no backseat calling, no hot-mic rage, say “afk 60s” instead of vanishing.
- No screenshots of private DMs in officer chat or anywhere else.
- Pre-existing friend groups are not a rank. Newcomers’ most common complaint in the research is cliques that formed in a previous game. Pods are deliberately mixed. verified
- Account sharing is prohibited. Blizzard’s EULA section 1.B.i.3 bans sharing your account or login. This applies to bank alts too; see Guild bank. verified How to secure your own account is on Get ready.
- Conduct reports are seen by two officers, acted on within 72 hours, and the outcome is told to the reporter. The Method collapse in 2020 is the reference case for what “we handled it internally” costs. verified
8. Removal and appeals
Section titled “8. Removal and appeals”Instant removal, no ladder: real-money trading, gold buying or selling, GDKP organizing under the guild’s name, scamming the bank, harassment, hate speech, and account sharing that puts the bank at risk.
Ladder removal: repeated no-shows without absence posts, voice conduct, and ninja-looting in pugs while wearing the tabard. The tabard is our reputation.
Inactivity: 90 days offline with no note gets a courtesy DM. Removal to the alumni list at 120 days. Never silent. Alumni can come back without awkwardness.
Appeals: 7 days for removals and conduct outcomes, to the GM, one written reply. Loot appeals are faster: 48 hours, per Loot rules. The GM can reverse a loot decision only for a rubric error, not for taste.
Announcements: only the fact, never the reasons. “X is no longer with us; questions to officers privately.”
Hardcore note: if any of us play the Hardcore ruleset when it arrives, deaths from disconnects or griefing are appealed to Blizzard with video proof, following Classic Hardcore community practice. The guild has no power over that appeal. vanilla baseline
9. How this charter changes
Section titled “9. How this charter changes”- Officers can change this charter. They post in the tavern when they do, with the version number and what changed.
- Loot rules never change mid-tier. Everything else can change at any monthly meeting.
- Any member can propose a change at the monthly meeting or by messaging an officer. An anonymous suggestion box is planned for year one.
- Backup GM: one of the three Flamewardens, named on the Officer handbook before launch. The
/gleaderhandover is rehearsed once before launch week.
Change log
Section titled “Change log”| Version | Date | Change |
|---|---|---|
| 1.0 | 2026-09-24 | First full charter, expanding the seven-line short charter pinned in Discord |
| 1.1 | 2026-10-08 | Guild name set to The True Torchmen after the name vote. Guild Master named: OrthodoxPaladinBueller (OPB). Rank names adopted: Keeper of the Flame, Flamewarden, Torchwarden, True Torchman, with Firebrand, Kindling and Ember reserved. Officer structure changed from “1 to 2, up to 5” to 2 Flamewardens and 3 founding Torchwardens. Ruleset recorded as decided: PvP, 7 to 0. Loot appeal window (48 hours) separated from removal appeals (7 days) |
| 1.2 | 2026-10-28 | ActaFooly promoted from Torchwarden to Flamewarden, so the officer structure is 3 Flamewardens and 2 founding Torchwardens. Total officers unchanged at five. The backup GM is now one of three Flamewardens and is still unnamed. Faction recorded as settled: Horde. The stale “faction undecided” lines were removed from the live pages; the dated pulse snapshots keep their original wording on purpose |
Unknown as of 2026-09-24
Section titled “Unknown as of 2026-09-24”- Forever’s charter cost and signature count. Vanilla: nine signatures plus the founder, 10 silver. Forever unannounced. Have ten people online. The beta temporarily accepts zero because of a bug.
- Whether Forever has any inactive-leader replacement rule. We assume none.
- Whether Forever’s servers offer master loot. The menu entry is in the client; see Loot systems. The loot rules are written to survive either answer.
- Number of in-game ranks and whether guild notes and officer notes work as in vanilla.
Sources
Section titled “Sources”- https://nickyee.com/pubs/Ducheneaut,%20Yee,%20Nickell,%20Moore%20-%20Chi%202007.pdf
- http://nickyee.com/pubs/Tree%20House%20to%20Barracks%202006.pdf
- https://www.pcgamesn.com/world-of-warcraft/forever-buying-gold-rmt-gdkp
- https://www.blizzard.com/en-us/legal/fba4d00f-c7e4-4883-b8b9-1b4500a402ea/blizzard-end-user-license-agreement
- https://warcraft.wiki.gg/wiki/Guild_leader
- https://guildorder.com/games/wow/guides/loot-systems-dkp-vs-epgp
- https://www.pcgamer.com/wows-top-competitive-raid-guild-is-collapsing-amid-multiple-accusations-of-sexual-assault-and-abuse/
- https://us.forums.blizzard.com/en/wow/t/hardcore-death-appeal/1586258
- Short charter and “How ranks work” embeds in the Discord start-here channel (internal)