Skip to content

Route rebuilds: Swiftthistle split by faction, Stonescale Eel kept sliding, and no clear route effect

Two fan sites rebuilt their leveling routes on 6 and 7 October, and both routes send players past Swiftthistle and Stonescale Eel. When a lot of players farm the same thing at once, its price can drop. We looked at whether that happened here, so you know whether the routes change what is worth picking up.

Did Swiftthistle and Stonescale Eel change price or supply after the routes were rebuilt, and did other herbs and fish move with them? A useful answer compares the two items with a control group: other herbs and fish that the routes did not single out. If the two route items moved and the control group did not, that is a hint. If everything moved, or the items moved the same way before the rebuild, the routes probably are not the story.

  • Swiftthistle went opposite ways on the two factions after 5 October: down 31.7% on PvP Horde, while the typical Horde herb fell 50.7%, and up 43.9% on PvP Alliance, while the typical Alliance herb rose 2.3%. A route effect would push both sides the same way, so this does not look like one.
  • Stonescale Eel fell from 37c to 12c on PvP Horde. That sounds big, but it is a few copper, and in the week before the rebuild its daily price already swung by 664% from its low day to its high day.
  • Swiftthistle was already climbing before the routes changed: up 95.3% on Alliance and 45.7% on Horde from 28 September to 5 October. A move after a date is not proof the date caused it, and here the price was moving well before the date.

We used the daily median price (the middle listing price of the day) and units listed (how many were up for sale) on both auction houses, PvP Horde and PvP Alliance, from 28 September to 14 October. That is a week before the first rebuild and a week after the second. The base day is 5 October, the last day before either route changed. The end point is the newest scan on 14 October.

For the control group we used every item the catalog files as a herb that was priced on both 5 October and 14 October: 16 herbs on Horde and 20 on Alliance. We took the median change across them, so one wild herb cannot drag the whole group. For fish, the catalog has no fish group, so we picked the raw fish that had at least 10 days of prices: Oily Blackmouth, Deviate Fish and Raw Nightfin Snapper. Three fish is a very small group, so treat it as a rough check only.

We also ran the same comparison on the week before the rebuild, 28 September to 5 October. If an item moved just as much in a week with no route change, a move after the change tells us little.

Our own calculations, not headline figures: on Horde, units listed for Swiftthistle rose about half from 5 October to 14 October, and for Stonescale Eel by about three quarters. On Alliance, Swiftthistle listings were about flat and Stonescale Eel listings nearly tripled. But 5 October was a low listing day for the eel on both sides, and the daily history and our own scans count listings in different ways, so we do not lean on these.

Swiftthistle on PvP Horde: the daily median price bounced between about 4 and 11 silver from late September, with no break on 6 or 7 October

Each dot is one day’s median price on Horde, the line is the 7 day median, and the bars under it are units listed. Look at 6 and 7 October: the price does not step down there. It keeps bouncing the way it did the week before.

Stonescale Eel on PvP Horde: a price of a few copper with sudden one day spikes, drifting lower through October

The eel sells for copper, not silver, and single days jump many times higher and fall back. The 7 day median was already drifting down before the rebuild. With a price this small and this jumpy, a fall of a few copper is not a signal.

Swiftthistle on both factions: Alliance has cost more than Horde for most of October, and both rose from late September

Red is Horde, blue is Alliance. Both lines climbed from late September, well before the routes changed. The last Alliance point is a single scan, and it jumps far above the days before it, which is why Alliance shows a rise.

Change in price from 5 to 14 October: Swiftthistle down on Horde and up on Alliance, with herbs and other fish just as mixed

Green bars rose, orange bars fell. If the routes had hit these two items, both items would sit apart from their control groups on both factions. They do not: herbs fell harder than Swiftthistle on Horde, and the other fish rose on Alliance while the eel fell.

  • If Swiftthistle and Stonescale Eel both fell on both factions over the next week of our own scans, while the herb and fish groups held flat, we would call that a real hint of more farming.
  • If the units listed for both items stayed well above their late September level for a full week of our own scans, measured the same way every day, that would point to more supply.
  • A sold-a-day estimate that climbs for the eel or the thistle over several days would also help. Today that estimate exists only for our newest scan, so we cannot compare it with the week before the rebuild.
  • If the fan sites publish when their traffic rose, we could check whether the timing lines up. Right now we only have the dates of the rebuild.

The beta has a level 30 cap, no raids and a small population, so a handful of players can move a price. The catalog lists Stonescale Eel as a level 45 item, above the cap, so few players can fish it at all, and its auction house is very thin. Most days in this window are daily history, and the days from 8 October on are our own scans. A daily figure and a single scan are not measured the same way, so the newest point can jump for that reason alone. The sold-a-day figure is an estimate. The beta is wiped before launch on November 4, so none of these prices carry over. What may carry over is the order of things: Swiftthistle is a herb that sells steadily, and the eel is cheap. This report cannot tell you that the routes changed any price, and it cannot tell you what these items will cost at launch.

For more, see The Terminal, Charts and the Herb page.