Skip to content

Loot systems: why we chose ours

Loot is where guilds die. Forever removes one option (GDKP is banned), leaves one half-answered question (master loot is in the interface, but nobody has seen the server offer it), and adds a new resource (raid-disenchant essences) that no vanilla loot system had a rule for. This page explains the systems, recommends one per raid size, and lists what the guild must write down before December 9. The binding rules themselves live on Loot rules; this page is the reasoning.

  • GDKP (gold-bid raids) is banned. Josh Greenfield (senior game designer) at the Sept 17 Q&A. Reasons: in regions where GDKP ran longest it “overtakes the traditional guild structure”, it is “a really big barrier to entry” for new and poorer players, and it launders bought gold. verified
  • The ban is regional. The ban covers North America and Europe realms only. Clay Stone told 4Gamers Taiwan it “won’t affect other regions,” per Wowhead on October 9. verified
  • Gold buying is “very aggressively” punished, up to permanent account loss. verified
  • The economy will be actively monitored with tunable drop and consumable availability; the Season of Discovery resource-box lever returns. verified
  • Enforcement of the GDKP rule itself: no published penalty ladder, no definition of what counts (a gold split for one BoE versus a full auction raid). One careful secondary source explicitly warns against inventing a suspension schedule. verified
  • Master loot vs group loot: not answered at the Q&A. One boost site asserts “loot distribution is group loot”. unverified See what the client shows below.
System How it works Good for Bad for
Soft reserve (SR) Each player names one item before the raid. If it drops, only reservers roll. Unreserved items go to open rolls. Small, weekly, trust-based groups. Lets people target a chase item. Long instances with many contested slots; tier for nine classes
MS>OS Main-spec need beats off-spec need. Usually paired with SR or open rolls. Everything. It is the floor. Needs a written definition of “main spec” per player
+1 Each item won adds a +1; players with fewer +1s win ties or roll first. Spreading loot across a farm raid Progression, where the right player matters more than fairness
Loot council (LC) Three named officers assign each drop by a written rubric: attendance, upgrade size, tier completion, role priority. Decisions logged publicly. Long raids with tier and crafted resources to allocate Trust. Needs a public log and a way to appeal.
GDKP Gold auctions, pot split. Nothing. Banned. Your account
Raid System Why
Barrow Deeps (10) SR + MS>OS + one item per run, roll /100, +1 tracking optional Small, trust-based, weekly. SR lets people target the chase item. Reserve declared before the first pull in the Discord thread.
Hyjal Summit (20) SR + MS>OS + one item per run until a core forms. Then loot council with a written rubric, public loot history 13 bosses, tier for 9 classes, essences for crafts: once a steady core exists, rolls waste a long instance. Council of 3, decisions logged the same night. The switch is announced two lockouts ahead.
Onyxia (40) The host guild’s rule when we join. Loot council with the rubric when we host One boss. Tier head vanilla baseline is the fight.

This table follows the binding text on Loot rules. If the two ever differ, Loot rules wins.

These are the decisions. The answers go on Loot rules.

  1. Tier priority order per class and role. With 2/3/4/5-piece bonuses, the 4th piece matters more than the 2nd. A player at 3 pieces outranks a player at 1 for the same slot. The 18 sets in the client, by class and role, with every bonus, are on Tier sets.
  2. Malleable Essence of Nature policy. Proposal: all disenchanted raid loot goes to the guild bank alt; the council assigns crafted pieces the same way it assigns drops. One designated Enchanter per raid. Nobody “wins” an essence on a roll.
  3. BoE epics from raids. Guild bank first, sold for consumable funds, or rolled. Pick one.
  4. Legendary questline. Name the first recipient in advance once the item and its class list are known. Do not let it be decided on the night it drops.
  5. Trial and casual-attendance priority. Below core raiders on contested items, equal on uncontested.
  6. Off-spec rule for the 1/3 healing-to-damage stat change. A healer’s +healing piece is MS for healers. A caster DPS piece is MS for casters. A healer piece is not “OS” for a caster just because it gives some damage, and a caster piece is not “OS” for a healer just because it could be worn. Single hit and crit stats also mean generic crit items are contested between melee and casters; name the priority.
  7. Transmog is never a Need reason on epics. Raid epic appearances go only to the looter, so “for the look” competes with real upgrades. Dungeon greens and blues give the appearance to everyone eligible, so there it is moot. See Transmog and mounts.
  8. One item per run at 10 unless nobody else wants it.

Malleable Essence of Nature comes only from disenchanting Barrow Deeps or Hyjal Summit drops and feeds roughly 72 crafted epic patterns sold in Mount Hyjal. datamined This is new: in vanilla a disenchanted drop was a Nexus Crystal nobody fought over. In Forever it is a tier-equivalent resource.

Proposal:

  • Designated Enchanter. One per raid, named in the Raid-Helper event. They receive every item that nobody needs, disenchant it in the raid, and mail the essences to the guild bank alt the same night.
  • Essence ledger. A pinned sheet: date, source item, count, current holder.
  • Crafted piece assignment. The loot council (or, at 10, the raid leader with the SR thread) assigns crafted pieces by the same rubric as drops. The crafter is paid mats from the bank; the recipient pays nothing.
  • Crafter obligation. Anyone who learns an essence pattern with guild essences crafts for the guild at no fee.
  • A possible equip cap. The client’s Rousing Seed Pod, a Guardians of Hyjal reward, raises “the limit of Artisan’s Tier items you can equip.” verified Game files, build 1.60.1.70338. The client’s limit table allows 1 equipped Artisan’s Tier piece, and the Seed Pod’s spell raises that to 2. datamined So hand crafted pieces out one per raider before anyone gets a second, and expect the second to wait for Revered with the Guardians of Hyjal.
  • Class mapping. The client gives it. Nine set names, one per class: Conviction (Priest), Demonheart (Warlock), Manaflare (Mage), Grimstitch (Rogue), Spiritcaller (Shaman), Grovekeeper (Druid), Wildstalker (Hunter), Justice (Paladin) and Glory (Warrior). They cover 18 sets by role and 72 recipes. datamined The table is on Tier sets. The priority list can now be written per class and role.

What the client shows, Game files, build 1.60.1.70338: verified

  • The group leader’s menu has a Loot Method entry. Its list holds Free for All, Round Robin, Master Looter, Group Loot and Need Before Greed, and a Loot Threshold sits beside it.
  • The Master Looter text is the Classic one: “the group leader is the only group member allowed to loot items at or above the threshold.”
  • Each method is shown only if the server reports it as available. That answer is not in the files, so the menu proves the option is built, not that it is switched on.
  • The slash command /master is still in the client.

Until a member sees the menu in a group, plan for both.

If master loot is gone, as on retail, then SR and loot council run on “need/greed/pass, then trade within the 2-hour window”, which is how retail guilds do it. Practical version:

  • Everyone passes on everything except their declared SR item or a council-assigned item.
  • Mis-rolls are traded to the correct player inside the trade window.
  • The Enchanter needs on unwanted items so they land with the disenchanter, not a random greed-roller.

If master loot exists, the raid leader or council assigns directly. Either way the written rules do not change; only the button does.

Forever runs the Midnight addon API. Classic Era addons do not load. verified See Addons.

Tool Forever status (checked on the dates shown) Use
Gargul No Forever flavor as of v8.0.0 (Sept 12). Listed a Forever file, v8.0.1-forever, on October 3 (CurseForge API check, 2026-10-04). verified That is the author’s claim, not a guild test. Test it on live before December 9; re-check on Dec 1. Whether it works without master loot is untested.
RCLootCouncil Forever file 3.26.0-beta.1-forever, published November 19 (CurseForge API check, 2026-11-19, 34.4M lifetime downloads). changed in Forever verified It had zero Forever files on October 28. That is the author’s claim, not a guild test, and the file calls itself a beta. Test it in a dungeon group before any raid plan leans on it. Until then, Gargul or manual.
EPGP Forever Real Forever file, EPGP_Forever_v1.5.0, 2026-10-21, but 190 total downloads. verified (CurseForge API, 2026-10-28) Only relevant if we ever leave soft reserve for a points system. Treat as an experiment nobody has raided with.
Arbiter Loot Council Forever file v0.7.0-beta-forever, 2026-10-06, 151 downloads, still beta. Its companion Arbiter Soft Reserve runs the exact phase-1 flow on this page: everyone answers main spec, off spec or pass, reservers roll first, leftovers fall to open main spec then off spec, every roll shown to the raid. verified (CurseForge API, 2026-10-28) Worth one test before December 9 because the flow matches our rules without configuration. Beta with 151 downloads, so it is a backup, not the plan.
softres.it Still no Forever support as of 2026-10-27. A Discord-bot maintainer has an open issue stating their soft reserve feature is blocked until softres.it ships a Forever edition code, with the Barrow Deeps, Hyjal and Onyxia mappings already written and waiting. unverified (third-party issue tracker) This is the real risk to phase 1. Both Gargul and Arbiter consume softres.it exports, so if it slips the reserve sheet is a manual Discord thread. Decide the fallback before December 9, not on the night.
ThatsMyBIS Lists Forever. verified Wishlists for loot council; item DB depth unknown.
Raid-Helper Game-agnostic. verified Signups.
DBM / BigWigs Forever-flagged. verified Boss timers once the raids exist.
Built-in damage meter and cooldown manager Confirmed by Blizzard, and both load in the Forever client. verified Game files, build 1.60.1.70338 Details! was not Forever-flagged on 09-19; it listed a Forever file on 09-25 (CurseForge API check, 2026-09-27), untested. verified
WeakAuras Dead on this API. verified None.
Warcraft Logs Unknown; no announcement found. unverified Do not promise logs.
Wowhead Forever DB Live, JS-only, has raid zones, factions, tier guide. Item lookups.

If nothing gains Forever support by December 9:

  1. Raid-Helper event for signups and roles.
  2. Discord thread per raid night where SRs are declared before the first pull.
  3. /roll in game, MS>OS, one item per run.
  4. Pinned sheet for loot history and the essence ledger, updated the same night.

It worked in 2005. It will work in December. The raid leader’s side of the night is on Raid leading.

  • Whether the servers offer master loot. The menu entry and its text are in the client.
  • GDKP enforcement: penalty ladder and what counts as a gold split.
  • Essence drop rates, and whether the Artisan’s Tier limit read from the client (1 piece, 2 after the Seed Pod) holds on live servers.
  • Legendary item and class eligibility.
  • softres.it and Warcraft Logs Forever support, and whether the Gargul and RCLootCouncil Forever files work in a real raid.
  • Boss-to-tier-slot mapping, which decides how contested each boss is.