Skip to content

Heavy Leather held its price as listings piled up, Silk Cloth collapsed

We asked a simple question: when more of a material shows up on the auction house, does its price drop? If you gather or craft, this tells you which materials can take a flood of sellers and which fall apart the moment everyone farms them.

When the number of units listed for a material goes up, some prices stay put and some sink. We wanted to find which materials hold their price as supply grows, and which collapse. A useful answer names a clear holder and a clear collapser, checks them on both factions, and says how common each pattern is.

  • Heavy Leather is the best holder. On Horde, units listed rose 354% from 23 September to 7 October, yet the median price moved only 1.7%. On Alliance, listings rose 1950.2% and the price still did not crash.
  • Silk Cloth is the clearest collapse. On Horde, listings rose 131.8% over the same two weeks and the median fell 77.4%. On Alliance it fell 79.7%.
  • There is no simple rule. Across the 95 Horde trade goods priced on both days, the middle price change was a rise of 23.6%, even though listings grew for many of them.

We looked at trade goods: herbs, ore, bars, stone, cloth, leather, enchanting materials, and the like. For each one we compared two days, 23 September and 7 October, which is two weeks. We used those two days because both come from AHledger’s daily history, so they are measured the same way. Our own scans start on 8 October and measure things a little differently, so mixing the two could create a jump that is not real.

For each material we took two numbers: how much the units listed changed, and how much the median price changed. The median is the middle price of everything listed, so a few silly listings do not move it much.

For the holder and the collapser we only kept materials with at least 20 units listed on 23 September. Below that, one player posting a stack can double the count, which tells you nothing. That left 77 materials on Horde and 78 on Alliance. We counted a material as a holder if its listings at least doubled and its price stayed within a few percent. We counted it as a collapse if its listings rose and its price lost more than half. We then checked each pick on the other faction.

As our own extra check, we ranked all 77 Horde materials by listing growth and by price change. The two rankings lean slightly against each other, so more listings goes with somewhat lower prices on average, but the link is weak and many materials go the other way.

Each dot is a Horde trade good: listing growth from 23 September to 7 October against price change, with no clear line

Each dot is one material. Further right means more units listed on 7 October than on 23 September. Higher means a higher price. A dot at 1 on both axes did not change. If more supply always meant lower prices, the dots would slope down from left to right. They mostly form a cloud. Heavy Leather sits about four and a half times right of 1 at a price of about 1. Silk Cloth sits a bit over two times right of 1, low down near a quarter of its old price.

Heavy Leather on Horde: the price wanders between about 8 and 15 silver while units listed climb

The blue line is the daily median price, the orange line the 7 day median, and the grey bars are units listed. Listings grew a lot from early October, and the price bounced around without breaking. It does drift a little lower in our own scans after 8 October, so “held” means “did not collapse”, not “stood still”.

Silk Cloth on Horde: the price falls from about 15 silver to under 3 silver as listings jump in early October

Silk Cloth is the textbook case. Listings jumped in the first days of October and the price fell off a cliff within days, then stayed low through our own scans. Bolt of Silk Cloth, made from it, fell the same way on both factions. One possible reason is a wave of players reaching the levels where Silk drops, but the data cannot show why.

If Heavy Leather’s 7 day median falls well below its late September level over the next two weeks while listings stay high, it stops being a holder and the call was just a lucky pair of days. If Silk Cloth’s price climbs back toward its old level while listings stay high, the collapse was a temporary glut, not a lasting one.

The bigger answer, that there is no simple rule, would change if a longer run of our own scans showed a clear downward slope in the cloud. That needs at least two more weeks of our own scans measured the same way, plus sold a day figures for each day, so we can tell “more listed because nobody buys” apart from “more listed and more bought”.

  • The beta caps characters at level 30 and has no raids. Materials needed past level 30 have little demand, so their prices may say more about a few players than about the market.
  • The population is small. One busy farmer can double the listings of a material in a day.
  • The beta is wiped before launch. None of these prices carry over. At best the order of things does, and even that is a guess until launch data exists.
  • We compared two single days. A price on one day can be an odd day. The charts show the full run so you can judge that yourself.
  • AHledger’s daily history and our own scans are measured differently. That is why we stopped the comparison at 7 October.
  • We have no sold a day figure for those two weeks, so we cannot tell whether a price held because buyers kept up or because sellers just waited.

For live prices see The Terminal and Charts. To decide what to do with drops you have now, see Sell or vendor.