The Market
The guild’s watchlist for the Forever economy. 60 materials, consumables and crafted items, each with a rating, a conviction from 1 to 5 and a thesis you can check. It is reviewed every day against Blizzard posts, patch notes and community reports, and every rating change is logged on Rating changes. New to this? Start with Sell now or hold and the Launch playbook. Full bags right now? Go to What do I do with my bags tonight. Want real auction prices? The Terminal reads the live beta auction house: what sells, what is vendor trash and what to gather for your mount on launch day.
What the ratings mean
Section titled “What the ratings mean”| Rating | What to do |
|---|---|
| ACCUMULATE | Gather or buy it and keep it. Demand should outrun supply in the window named in the thesis. |
| BUY DIPS | Worth owning, but not at any price. Buy when the launch flood or a weekend glut pushes it down. |
| HOLD | If you have it, keep it for your own crafting or for a better selling window. Do not chase more. |
| SELL EARLY | After launch, sell it in the first week or two. It is worth the most while everyone is leveling at once, and less every week after. |
| WATCH | No call yet. Something about it is unknown or unconfirmed. Do not spend gold on it. |
| AVOID | Do not buy it to resell and do not craft it for profit. |
Conviction is how sure the call is, 1 (a hunch) to 5 (rests on confirmed Forever data and a clear mechanism).
Highest conviction calls
Section titled “Highest conviction calls”- Mild Spices: AVOID, 5 of 5. Vendor item. First Aid potions need Mild, Hot or Soothing Spices, so carry a stack. Never buy it on the auction house. verified
- Dreamfoil: ACCUMULATE, 4 of 5. Elixir of the Owl (4), Major Mender’s Potion (3), Major Mana Potion (3) and Major Spellblasting (2) all want it. The caster raid herb. verified
- Frilled Lichen: ACCUMULATE, 4 of 5. Scarce herbalism drop. Alchemists turn 2 into a Cerulean Dye, and over 100 new Tailoring recipes take that dye. unverified
- Golden Sansam: ACCUMULATE, 4 of 5. Four new level 60 elixirs and a new flask use it, and the First Aid Major Healing Potion takes one each. A broad raid night herb. verified
- Gromsblood: ACCUMULATE, 4 of 5. Cheap in vanilla. Forever makes it the melee elixir herb: Grizzly, Ferocity and Venomous Blood. verified
The board
Section titled “The board”ACCUMULATE
Section titled “ACCUMULATE”Gather or buy it and keep it. Demand should outrun supply in the window named in the thesis.
| Item | Category | Conviction | Thesis | Evidence | Guild |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dreamfoil | Herbs | 4 of 5 | Elixir of the Owl (4), Major Mender’s Potion (3), Major Mana Potion (3) and Major Spellblasting (2) all want it. The caster raid herb. | verified | |
| Frilled Lichen | New in Forever | 4 of 5 | Scarce herbalism drop. Alchemists turn 2 into a Cerulean Dye, and over 100 new Tailoring recipes take that dye. | unverified | |
| Golden Sansam | Herbs | 4 of 5 | Four new level 60 elixirs and a new flask use it, and the First Aid Major Healing Potion takes one each. A broad raid night herb. | verified | |
| Gromsblood | Herbs | 4 of 5 | Cheap in vanilla. Forever makes it the melee elixir herb: Grizzly, Ferocity and Venomous Blood. | verified | |
| Kingsblood | Herbs | 4 of 5 | Three new low-level caster and healer elixirs all eat Kingsblood. It was a filler herb in vanilla. It is not one now. | verified | |
| Strange Dust | Enchanting materials | 4 of 5 | Enchanters need 176 to level and the Enchanted Lute camp object burns it every time it is crafted. | verified | |
| Sungrass | Herbs | 4 of 5 | The new tank elixirs (Greater Fortitude, Phalanx) take 4 Sungrass each. Vanilla barely used it. | verified | |
| Mithril Ore | Ore, bars and stone | 3 of 5 | The classic leveling chokepoint for both mining crafts. Today’s route lists ask for more of it than vanilla did, mostly above the beta cap. | vanilla baseline | |
| New raid elixirs | Consumables | 3 of 5 | Forever adds a 30-minute elixir for every role. Stock the herbs, not the elixirs, until stacking rules are known. | verified | We can craft it |
| Pristine Leather | New in Forever | 3 of 5 | A Scarce drop from skinning that new recipes in other professions need. Never vendor one. | unverified | |
| Rugged Leather | Leather | 3 of 5 | Level 60 leather for armor kits and every late leather and mail set. Raid-night staple. | vanilla baseline |
BUY DIPS
Section titled “BUY DIPS”Worth owning, but not at any price. Buy when the launch flood or a weekend glut pushes it down.
| Item | Category | Conviction | Thesis | Evidence | Guild |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oily Blackmouth | Cooking and fishing | 4 of 5 | Every alchemist needs about 62 for Blackmouth Oil on the 80 to 130 stretch of today’s route. Few people fish at launch. | verified | |
| Runecloth | Cloth | 4 of 5 | Level 60 cloth: 14-slot bags, the last bandages, late Tailoring. Everyone at 60 farms it without trying. | vanilla baseline | |
| Elemental Fire | Elementals | 3 of 5 | Fire Protection and fire oil material, and Onyxia is a launch raid. Buy before December. | vanilla baseline | |
| Greater Fire Protection Potion | Consumables | 3 of 5 | Onyxia opens December 9 with no attunement. Fire protection is the one resistance consumable a launch raid asks for. | vanilla baseline | We can craft it |
| Heavy Leather | Leather | 3 of 5 | The 150 to 225 leatherworking stretch needs more crafts than vanilla. Medium and Heavy Leather are the wall. | verified | |
| Illusion Dust | Enchanting materials | 3 of 5 | Level 60 enchant dust. Every raider needs a set of enchants before December 9. | verified | |
| Mageweave Cloth | Cloth | 3 of 5 | Correction: 230 for Tailoring to 225 on today’s source, not 685. Still thin when the first players reach 40, so buy the dips. | vanilla baseline | |
| Silk Cloth | Cloth | 3 of 5 | 448 for Tailoring to 225, 126 for bandages, plus 10-slot bags. Plentiful, so buy the gluts. | verified | |
| Stonescale Eel | Cooking and fishing | 3 of 5 | Stonescale Oil is on today’s Alchemy route from 250 and in the tank flask. Night-time coastal catch, few fishers. | verified | |
| Thorium Ore | Ore, bars and stone | 3 of 5 | Feeds the last 50 points of two crafts and Arcanite. Buy the dips before raids open. | vanilla baseline | |
| Firebloom | Herbs | 2 of 5 | Dragonfire Potion, Elemental Purging, Mender’s Potion and Cleric’s Elixir are new sinks. The leveling route no longer burns it. | verified |
If you have it, keep it for your own crafting or for a better selling window. Do not chase more.
| Item | Category | Conviction | Thesis | Evidence | Guild |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arcanite Bar | Ore, bars and stone | 4 of 5 | Made on a 2-day transmute cooldown. Supply is capped by the number of alchemists, not by farming. | vanilla baseline | |
| Large Brilliant Shard | Enchanting materials | 4 of 5 | From disenchanting level 60 dungeon blues. The limiting material for the best enchants in every Classic launch. | vanilla baseline | |
| Major Healing Potion | Consumables | 4 of 5 | First Aid 275. The guild needs 60 to 100 a raid night and every raider makes their own. | verified | We can craft it |
| Major Mana Potion | Consumables | 4 of 5 | Alchemy keeps mana potions and only alchemists can make them. Our plan is about 50 a raid night. | verified | We can craft it |
| Runecloth Bag | Crafted gear and bags | 4 of 5 | 14 slots, the level 60 standard. With 8 bank bag slots, each character can use up to 12 of them. | vanilla baseline | We can craft it |
| Waylaid Supply Crate | New in Forever | 4 of 5 | The only way to earn Merchant’s Favor, and gold cannot buy Favor. Never sell a crate. Fill it or pass it to a guild crafter. | verified | |
| Essence of Water | Elementals | 3 of 5 | The Forever client names it in about 50 recipes across seven trades. Keep what drops. Dedicated Study adds a new supply. | verified | |
| Greater Eternal Essence | Enchanting materials | 3 of 5 | Level 60 essence for stat enchants. Keep for the guild enchant night. | vanilla baseline | |
| Iron Ore | Ore, bars and stone | 3 of 5 | Steady demand from Blacksmithing and Engineering 150 to 225, and a new dungeon quest takes 12 bars. Use your own, sell the extra to crafters. | vanilla baseline | |
| Linen Cloth | Cloth | 3 of 5 | Everyone needs it for First Aid, which now matters to every character. Keep your own, do not expect a profit. | vanilla baseline | |
| Raw Nightfin Snapper | Cooking and fishing | 3 of 5 | Nightfin Soup and Grilled Squid are still raid foods in the client, with new buffs. Grilled Squid needs an Iron Oven. | vanilla baseline | |
| Wool Cloth | Cloth | 3 of 5 | Correction: the 807 Wool figure is gone. The source reads 390 today, a second site 111. Keep Wool for bags, do not stockpile it. | vanilla baseline | |
| Black Lotus | Herbs | 2 of 5 | Flask herb. The five vanilla flasks still take one each. A Blizzard interview points to merchants selling it capped at 50 gold, which limits how far the price can climb. | verified | |
| Tin Ore | Ore, bars and stone | 2 of 5 | The 602 Bronze Bar figure is gone from the source. It reads 356 today and a second site says 135. Keep Tin for Bronze, do not stockpile it. | vanilla baseline |
SELL EARLY
Section titled “SELL EARLY”After launch, sell it in the first week or two. It is worth the most while everyone is leveling at once, and less every week after.
| Item | Category | Conviction | Thesis | Evidence | Guild |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Copper Ore | Ore, bars and stone | 4 of 5 | Every blacksmith, engineer and enchanter needs copper in the first three days. Sell then, not later. | vanilla baseline | |
| Light Leather | Leather | 4 of 5 | Skinning went back to one skin per corpse and Leatherworking now needs more crafts per skill bracket. Sell in week one. | verified | |
| Expert First Aid manual | Vendor reagents | 3 of 5 | Sold only by remote vendors. Everyone needs First Aid now, so more buyers than vanilla. | verified | |
| Lesser Healing Potion | Consumables | 3 of 5 | Healing potions are First Aid now. Alchemists no longer flood them, and most players will not notice until they need one. | verified | We can craft it |
| Peacebloom | Herbs | 3 of 5 | Alchemists need about 86 for the first stretch and First Aid takes about 40 more for Minor Healing Potions. It grows everywhere. Sell the surplus in week one. | verified | |
| Rough Stone | Ore, bars and stone | 3 of 5 | Blacksmiths level on sharpening stones and engineers on blasting powder. Miners should not vendor it in week one. | verified | |
| Spider’s Silk | Cloth | 3 of 5 | Spider drop that the new Silky cloth and Skulker’s leather recipes use. Launch scans show it selling several times vendor. List it, do not vendor it. | unverified | |
| Stat food with the XP bonus | Cooking and fishing | 3 of 5 | Crafted food now gives a small experience bonus. Levelers will buy it for as long as they are leveling. | verified | We can craft it |
| Lesser Magic Wand | Crafted gear and bags | 2 of 5 | Enchanter-made wands were the best early caster weapon in 2019. Blizzard cut their vendor price, not their use. | vanilla baseline | We can craft it |
| Small Silk Pack | Crafted gear and bags | 2 of 5 | 10-slot bags at level 30. Guild scans show the price falling early in week two, so sell packs you make while leveling now and do not craft them for profit. | vanilla baseline | We can craft it |
No call yet. Something about it is unknown or unconfirmed. Do not spend gold on it.
| Item | Category | Conviction | Thesis | Evidence | Guild |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Azerothium Bar | New in Forever | 3 of 5 | New Mining 275 smelt from Pitchblende and Coal for new endgame crafts. Where Pitchblende comes from is unknown. | verified | |
| Camp Blueprints | New in Forever | 3 of 5 | Tier 2 and 3 camp objects need Blueprints from dungeon bosses. If they can be traded, they are the first big-ticket drops. | verified | |
| Camp objects | New in Forever | 3 of 5 | The October 30 build makes the Adventurer’s Tent a cosmetic 15 min tent again, reverting the rested experience version. Back to a small tips market at dungeon entrances. | verified | We can craft it |
| Flask of Supreme Power | Consumables | 3 of 5 | Confirmed in the client with eight other flasks. May need an Alchemy Laboratory at camp to craft. | verified | We can craft it |
| Ghost Mushroom | Herbs | 3 of 5 | The new thrown smog potions take 2 to 3 each and the herb has very few spawn points. Slow to start. PvP will decide it. | verified | |
| Free Action Potion | Consumables | 2 of 5 | Correction: today’s Alchemy route no longer levels on Free Action Potions, so the flood call is withdrawn. Swim Speed Potions are still a route step. | vanilla baseline | We can craft it |
| Torbernite | New in Forever | 1 of 5 | New ore and herbs with no known node, zone or drop source. The client names them in a few level 60 recipes. | unverified |
Do not buy it to resell and do not craft it for profit.
| Item | Category | Conviction | Thesis | Evidence | Guild |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mild Spices | Vendor reagents | 5 of 5 | Vendor item. First Aid potions need Mild, Hot or Soothing Spices, so carry a stack. Never buy it on the auction house. | verified | |
| Crafted leveling armor | Crafted gear and bags | 4 of 5 | Quest greens are as good and free. Crafted whites and greens before 40 do not sell. | vanilla baseline | We can craft it |
| Empty Vial | Vendor reagents | 4 of 5 | Vendor item used by every potion, elixir and the Mana Well. Stock it, do not flip it. | verified | |
| Simple Wood | Vendor reagents | 4 of 5 | Vendor item for campfire kits and the Enchanted Lute. Carry it, do not trade it. | verified | |
| Linen Bag | Crafted gear and bags | 3 of 5 | Starter quests now hand out 6-slot bags. The 6-slot bag market from 2019 is mostly gone. | verified | We can craft it |
| Mote of Magic | New in Forever | 3 of 5 | Its source is now known: enchanting vendors sell it and enchanters make 3 from 1 Strange Dust. No market to chase. | verified | |
| Woolen Bag | Crafted gear and bags | 2 of 5 | Guild scans show the 8-slot bag falling below the value of the Wool it takes. Do not craft Woolen Bags to sell. Sell the Wool instead. | verified | We can craft it |
Latest rating changes
Section titled “Latest rating changes”- 2026-11-20, Runecloth: new risk added. Wowhead reports that Skyborne players reach Honored for a mount discount through Runecloth turn-ins and will need a lot of Runecloth. The row listed Runecloth reputation turn-ins as unconfirmed for Forever. This confirms a demand source the thesis did not count, so the note is added. Rating and conviction stay the same. Sources: Skyborne Now Get Reputation Discount for Mounts in WoW:…
- 2026-11-19, Runecloth Bag: new risk added. Wowhead reports a questline open to every class that rewards a free 16-slot Red Bag. That is bigger than the 14 slot Runecloth Bag and takes a carried bag slot a Runecloth Bag would have filled, so demand per character is a little lower. The rating and conviction stay because bank bag slots still need bags. Sources: Earn a Free 16-Slot Bag from a Former SoD Questline in…
- 2026-11-15, Iron Ore: thesis updated. Wowhead’s Krol’dok Stronghold guide says both factions need 12 Iron Bars and 4 Thick Leather for the quest Key Ingredients in the new level 40 to 45 dungeon. That is a new Forever sink for Iron Bars, so the thesis now names it. It is a small sink and guild scans show the ore price falling, so the rating and conviction stay. Sources: Infiltrate Krol’dok Stronghold: New Dungeon in WoW: Forever
- 2026-11-13, Small Silk Pack: conviction 3 to 2. Guild Auctionator scans show the Small Silk Pack at 3700 to 4200 copper on 2026-11-07 and 2200 on 2026-11-12. This row called it a steady seller through weeks two to four, but the price fell sharply at the start of week two, so conviction drops and the thesis now says to sell skill-up packs now and not craft them for profit.
- 2026-11-13, Woolen Bag: rating SELL EARLY to AVOID. Guild Auctionator scans show the Woolen Bag at 1200 copper on 2026-11-06, 1000 on 2026-11-07 and 500 on 2026-11-10, and the Wool Cloth scan that day put the 9 Wool a bag takes above the price of the bag. The first week window this row named has closed, so crafting bags to sell now loses against selling the Wool.
Full log: Rating changes.
Sources
Section titled “Sources”- https://foreverchanges.pro/professions/alchemy
- https://www.wowhead.com/forever/guide/camping-overview-unlock-rewards
- https://classicwowforever.com/legacy/
- https://foreverchanges.pro/professions/herbalism
- https://foreverchanges.pro/professions/first-aid
- https://wow.gg/guides/wow-forever-new-recipes-alchemy
- https://foreverchanges.pro/professions/alchemy/recipes
- https://www.pcgamesn.com/world-of-warcraft/forever-buying-gold-rmt-gdkp
- https://expcarry.com/wow-forever-alchemy-guide
- https://foreverchanges.pro/professions/blacksmithing
- https://foreverchanges.pro/professions/engineering
- https://foreverchanges.pro/professions/mining
- https://www.mmojugg.com/news/wow-forever-enchanting-guide.html
- https://classicwowforever.com/professions/blacksmithing/
- https://classicwowforever.com/professions/blacksmithing/leveling/
- https://ahledger.com
- https://foreverchanges.pro/professions/tailoring
- https://www.wowhead.com/forever/guide/professions/first-aid/overview
- https://classicwowforever.com/professions/tailoring/leveling/
- https://www.wowhead.com/forever/news/default-bank-size-doubled-in-wow-forever-382995
- https://foreverchanges.pro/professions/leatherworking
- https://classicwowforever.com/professions/leatherworking/
- https://www.wowhead.com/news=383226/skinning-no-longer-group-wide-in-latest-wow-forever-beta-build
- https://foreverchanges.pro/professions/skinning
- https://foreverchanges.pro/professions/enchanting
- https://www.wowhead.com/news=383224/no-more-easy-money-with-enchanting-flips-in-wow-forever-sell-cost-nerfed
- https://blizzardwatch.com/2026/09/21/every-new-enchant-world-warcraft-forever/
- https://www.wowhead.com/news=383078/buy-gear-pets-mounts-and-more-on-the-wow-forever-black-market-auction-house
- https://foreverchanges.pro/professions/fishing
- https://foreverchanges.pro/professions/cooking
- https://classicwowforever.com/professions/cooking/
- https://worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com/en-us/news/24303313/world-of-warcraft-forever-deep-dive-panel-recap
- https://foreverchanges.pro/professions/cooking/recipes
- https://lfcarry.com/guides/wow-forever-gold-economy
- https://foreverchanges.pro/professions
- https://hostedgg.com/blog/wow-forever-professions-changes
- https://www.wowhead.com/forever/guide/azeroth-commerce-authority-reputation-professions
- https://www.classicquester.com/news/bigger-bank-reagent-bag-starter-bags
- https://www.warcrafttavern.com/forever/news/new-blacksmithing-plans-for-world-of-warcraft-forever/
- https://www.reddit.com/r/classicwowplus/comments/1wzp9cn/waylaid_supply_crates_and_crafting
- https://classicwowforever.com/professions/camping/
- https://www.icy-veins.com/wow-forever/news/every-gathering-node-in-wow-forever-can-drop-a-scarce-material-youll-want/
- https://goldboosting.com/blog/wows-forever-merchants-favor-hidden-new-currency-guide
- https://lfcarry.com/guides/wow-forever-camping
- https://www.warcrafttavern.com/forever/news/new-engineering-schematics-for-world-of-warcraft-forever/
- https://www.wowhead.com/classic/items