Beta prices back the sell early and accumulate calls, but hold items fell hardest
The rated board says what to do with key materials after launch. We checked each call against four weeks of beta auction prices to see which way the prices moved. This is a sanity check of direction, not a score, and it shows where the board and the beta disagree.
The question
Section titled “The question”Each item on the board has a rating: SELL EARLY, ACCUMULATE, BUY DIPS, HOLD, WATCH or AVOID. A rating is a plan for after launch. The beta server has now run for about four weeks, and that is a small version of a fresh server: players level up, low level materials pile up, and some things get scarce. So we can ask a simple question. Did the beta prices move the way each rating expects? SELL EARLY items should fall as a server ages. ACCUMULATE items should hold up or rise. HOLD items should stay roughly steady. A useful answer names the groups where the beta agrees, the groups where it does not, and the groups the beta cannot judge at all.
The short answer
Section titled “The short answer”- SELL EARLY agrees: on PvP Horde the typical sell early item fell 31.1% from late September to the newest scan, and 7 of 9 got cheaper. On PvP Alliance the same group fell 44.2%.
- ACCUMULATE mostly agrees: the typical accumulate item rose 25.5% on Horde and 38.7% on Alliance over the same stretch, but in the last two weeks alone the Horde group moved only 2%, so the rise is old news, not a trend.
- HOLD is contradicted: hold items fell hardest of any group, down 50.3% on Horde and 77.7% on Alliance, and only 6 of the hold items on Horde had a price at both ends.
Method
Section titled “Method”We took every item on the rated board that has an item id and grouped them by rating. For each item we compared its daily median price on 23 September with its daily median price on 17 October, on each faction’s market. Then we took the median change inside each group. A median change is the middle value: half the items in the group moved more, half moved less. That keeps one wild item from swinging the whole group.
We chose 23 September as the start because it is the first day both factions have a price. The window is a little over three weeks. We also looked at the last two weeks on their own (3 to 17 October) and at the first two weeks on their own (23 September to 7 October), so we could see if a result held up or only came from one stretch. No minimum sales or price filter was used: the board is short, and every rated item counts.
An item only counts in a group when it has a price on both days. Several rated items never trade in the beta at all, so some groups are tiny. On Horde, HOLD has 13 rated items but only six with a price at both ends. WATCH has only one priced item (Free Action Potion), so we do not judge WATCH here.
Some of what sits behind the headline, from our own reading of the same prices:
- The two sell early items that rose on Horde were Copper Ore and Peacebloom. Both sit at a few silver or less, where a single listing can move the median a lot.
- In the accumulate group, Kingsblood rose sharply in the last few days on both factions. Sungrass, Gromsblood and Strange Dust fell. Strange Dust dropped on the day our own scans began, which looks more like the change in how prices are measured than a real move.
- The hold fall comes mostly from Linen Cloth, Wool Cloth and Raw Nightfin Snapper. These are leveling materials, and in the beta they behaved like sell early items: cheap and getting cheaper as players leveled past them. Iron Ore was the only hold item on Horde that rose.
- BUY DIPS and AVOID swung from one window to the next, and between factions. Their group numbers are too noisy to call either way.
Charts
Section titled “Charts”Each bar is one rating group. Green bars went up, orange bars went down. The count next to each rating shows how many items had a price at both ends. Read the sign more than the size: the groups are small.
The Alliance market tells the same story for the three groups that matter here: sell early down, accumulate up, hold down. BUY DIPS and AVOID point different ways on the two factions, which is one reason we do not call them.
Each panel is one item with its own price scale, so compare the shape, not the height. This grid starts on 21 September, two days before our group window, so its percent figures differ a little from the bars. The cloth panels (Linen, Wool) show the hold problem clearly: a step down in early October, then flat. Kingsblood shows how fresh the accumulate rise is.
You can see the full board with live prices on The Terminal and more price charts on Charts.
What would change this
Section titled “What would change this”- If the HOLD cloth and fish recover on both factions over the last week of the beta, the hold contradiction weakens. If they keep falling, the board should ask whether Linen Cloth, Wool Cloth and Raw Nightfin Snapper behave more like SELL EARLY items.
- If the accumulate herbs that are above the beta skill cap (Sungrass, Golden Sansam, Dreamfoil, Gromsblood) go on falling in our own scans through the end of the beta, the beta gives no support to those calls at all. Their real test is after launch, when players can reach level 50 to 60 zones and the raid recipes.
- If the sell early group stops falling once the beta population settles, the “sell in week one” timing gets weaker support. What would back it best is a clear fall in the first week after November 4, which only launch data can show.
- If Kingsblood’s late jump fades within a few days, the recent part of the accumulate rise was noise.
Limits of beta data
Section titled “Limits of beta data”- The beta has a level 30 cap and no raids. Most accumulate herbs, all the raid potions and Arcanite Bar are out of reach, so their beta prices tell us almost nothing about launch demand.
- The population is small. A few players can set the price of a rarely traded item.
- The beta is wiped before launch. Nothing here carries over, and a beta price is not a launch price. What may carry over is the order of things, which items fall and which hold up.
- Until 7 October the prices are AHledger’s daily history. From 8 October they are our own scans. The two are measured differently, so a jump on 8 October can come from the method alone. Strange Dust is the clearest case.
- We compared two single days. Daily medians on cheap items jump around a lot, so a different start or end day can change a group’s number by many points. The sign held in both factions for sell early, accumulate and hold, which is why we only call those three.
- WATCH, and many HOLD and BUY DIPS items, have no beta price at all. This page cannot tell you whether those calls are right.
Sources
Section titled “Sources”- https://ahledger.com
- https://ahledger.com/developers
- https://ahledger.com/items/3356-kingsblood/forever.pvp.horde.us
- https://ahledger.com/items/2589-linen-cloth/forever.pvp.horde.us
- https://ahledger.com/items/2592-wool-cloth/forever.pvp.horde.us
- https://ahledger.com/items/13759-raw-nightfin-snapper/forever.pvp.horde.us
- https://ahledger.com/items/10940-strange-dust/forever.pvp.horde.us