The auction house pays less than the vendor on 56 Horde items
Some items look like auction house goods and are not. You list them, you wait, you pay the house cut, and you walk away with less than the vendor in town would have handed you on the spot. We went through the newest full scan of both auction houses to find every item like that, and to see how much traffic actually runs through them.
The question
Section titled “The question”Which items look worth auctioning but actually pay less than a vendor, and how many players get caught by them?
A useful answer has three parts. First, a count: how many items on the auction house net no more than the vendor pays. Second, a shape: what kind of items they are, so you can recognise one without a list. Third, an honest statement about the “how many players” half of the question, because the price data has no players in it at all.
The test we use is simple. Take the kinder of today’s median price and the 7 day median, subtract the 5 percent the auction house keeps, and compare that to the vendor price. If what is left is no more than the vendor pays, the item is a vendor trap.
The short answer
Section titled “The short answer”- On the Horde auction house, 56 items pay no more than a vendor once the house takes its cut. That is 2.7% of the items that have a vendor price at all. On Alliance it is 47 items, or 2.3%.
- Not one rare item is a trap. On Horde, all 181 rare items with a vendor price clear the vendor comfortably. The traps are ordinary stock instead: 27 uncommon items and 25 common ones.
- We cannot count players. The data counts items and sales, never people. The nearest measure is traffic: trap items move 6,867 units a day on Horde, and a single one of them, Crisp Spider Meat, is 40.4% of that flow by itself.
Method
Section titled “Method”We used the newest complete scan of each auction house, taken on 21 October 2026, with 2,206 priced items on PvP Horde and 2,156 on PvP Alliance. A complete scan is the only kind of data that can answer this question, because it carries the vendor price alongside the auction price for every item, and it is the only kind that carries an estimate of how many units sell a day.
An item counts as a vendor trap when three things are true. It has a vendor price above zero. We take the higher of its current median auction price and its 7 day median, which is the kinder of the two readings and gives the auction house the benefit of the doubt. And after the 5 percent cut the auction house keeps on a sale, that figure is still no more than the vendor pays.
We chose the kinder of the two price readings on purpose. Using the lower one would have swept in items that simply had a slow day, and the list would have looked alarming without being true. Items with no vendor price at all are excluded, because a vendor will not buy them and there is nothing to compare.
One number in the report is our own arithmetic rather than a measured figure: adding up the shortfall on every trap item, multiplied by its estimated daily sales, comes to roughly 11 gold a day across the whole Horde auction house and roughly 13 gold a day on Alliance. That is the size of the entire problem on a realm. It is small.
The reason it is small is in the second chart. The auction house keeps 5 percent of every sale, so an item listed at exactly the vendor price lands about 5 percent short before anything else goes wrong. Most of the 56 Horde traps are in that band. Only two of them are more than 10 percent below the vendor, and three on Alliance.
Charts
Section titled “Charts”Read this as “where the traps live”. They cluster in uncommon gear and common materials, the two groups with the most items on the board. The rare bars are empty on both sides, which is the useful part: if an item is rare quality, the auction house is paying more than the vendor for it.
This is the whole story in one picture. Two items are badly mispriced. Everything below them is within a few percent of the vendor price, which is mostly just the house cut biting. On those, vendoring saves you a copper or two and the wait, not a fortune.
The real traps are crafted bronze mail. Rough Bronze Leggings vendor for 9s 62c and net 5s 70c at auction, so every pair sold on the board loses 3s 92c against simply vendoring it. Patterned Bronze Bracers lose 2s 37c. Both are traps on Alliance too: the leggings show the identical gap there and sell about twice as often, and the bracers miss by 1s 34c. The likely reason is supply. These are level 21 to 25 crafting pieces, the kind made in batches while a profession goes up, and the board holds more of them than anyone wants.
What would change this
Section titled “What would change this”Three things would move the answer.
A real gap appearing in a third item, or a gap widening past 10 percent on something with steady sales, would turn this from a two item story into a pattern. We check the same test on every complete scan, so that would show up within a day.
Supply drying up would end it. The bronze armour gap exists because levelling blacksmiths list their practice pieces. If the number listed falls and the median climbs back above the vendor price, the trap closes on its own.
A level cap rise would reset the whole list. Vendor prices are fixed by the item, but auction prices are driven by what people are levelling through right now. Bronze gear is a level 21 to 25 band item. Push the cap and a different band of gear takes its place on the board, with its own traps.
What would not change the answer is more days of history. This question needs one complete scan with vendor prices, not a long series, so waiting does not make it sharper.
Limits of beta data
Section titled “Limits of beta data”This cannot tell you how many players are affected. The price data has items, prices and an estimate of units sold. It has no characters, no names and no way to tell one seller listing 40 pairs of leggings from 40 sellers listing one each. When we say 6,867 units a day, that is units, and a large part of it is one cheap cooking ingredient.
Sold a day is an estimate, and it exists only in the newest scan. Most days in our history are daily summaries from AHledger with about 320 items and no sales figure, so a single scan and a daily summary are not measured the same way. Everything in this report comes from the single newest scan on each side.
The beta runs at a level 30 cap with no raids and a small population. The item mix on the board is a levelling economy, which is why the traps are levelling gear. Prices here are not launch prices. The beta is wiped before launch on November 4, so the numbers are worthless afterwards. What is likely to survive is the shape: cheap crafted levelling gear made in bulk tends to sit near or under its vendor price, and rare items do not.
The 5 percent house cut used here is the standard auction house fee. If Forever changes it at launch, the whole boundary moves with it.
For the per item view, see Sell or vendor and The Terminal.
Sources
Section titled “Sources”- https://ahledger.com
- https://ahledger.com/developers
- https://ahledger.com/items/2865-rough-bronze-leggings/forever.pvp.horde.us
- https://ahledger.com/items/2868-patterned-bronze-bracers/forever.pvp.horde.us
- https://ahledger.com/items/2866-rough-bronze-cuirass/forever.pvp.horde.us
- https://ahledger.com/items/2865-rough-bronze-leggings/forever.pvp.alliance.us