Skip to content

Market: Cooking and fishing

4 items in this group. The short version is on the board. Ratings are theses, not prices. See Methodology.

Item Rating Conviction Evidence
Oily Blackmouth BUY DIPS 4 of 5 verified
Stonescale Eel BUY DIPS 3 of 5 verified
Raw Nightfin Snapper HOLD 3 of 5 vanilla baseline
Stat food with the XP bonus SELL EARLY 3 of 5 verified

BUY DIPS, conviction 4 of 5. verified Last changed 2026-11-12, see Rating changes.

Oily Blackmouth is fished from coastal waters and makes Blackmouth Oil (2 fish each). Checked 2026-10-08, the foreverchanges Alchemy route makes Blackmouth Oil from 80 to 96 and Swim Speed Potions from 100 to 130, and its skill 1 to 225 list asks for 62 Oily Blackmouth. The Free Action Potion (2 Blackmouth Oil) is still in the client at 150 but is no longer a step on the route, which this row said before. Few people level Fishing at launch, so the fish is scarcer than the demand suggests.

Demand

  • Alchemy leveling: 62 on the foreverchanges skill 1 to 225 list (checked 2026-10-08)
  • Blackmouth Oil for Swim Speed Potion and Free Action Potion

Supply

  • Source: Fishing coastal waters and pools, skill 1 to 150 zones
  • Competition: low
  • Level range: 10 to 40
  • Used by: Alchemy
  • Comes from: Fishing
  • Price: 1s 78c lowest buyout on PvP, scanned 2026-11-14
Phase Do Why
Launch week GATHER Fishers: catch it from the start.
Weeks 2 to 4 SELL Sell to alchemists on the 80 to 130 stretch.
Raids open (December 9) and after HOLD Free Action Potions for PvP.

What would break this

  • The count is a fan site route that changed between late September and 2026-10-08.
  • The Fishing Rack camp object catches uncommon fish hourly and could add supply.

Evidence: foreverchanges.pro, foreverchanges.pro, wowhead.com

BUY DIPS, conviction 3 of 5. verified Last changed 2026-10-08, see Rating changes.

Checked 2026-10-08 against foreverchanges: one Stonescale Eel makes two Stonescale Oil at Alchemy 250. Flask of the Titans takes 10 oil, Flask of Petrification 30, Greater Stoneshield Potion 3, and the armor elixir the client calls Elixir of Greater Defense takes 2. The Alchemy route now runs Stonescale Oil and that elixir from 250 to 295 and lists 34 eels. All of it is above the beta skill cap of 225. The eel is caught mostly at night in level 45 to 60 coastal waters, and few players have Fishing high enough in the first month. Beta realm prices from AHledger on 2026-10-08, not launch prices: the eel sells for several times its 7-day median on both factions.

Demand

  • Alchemy leveling: 34 on the foreverchanges skill 225 to 300 list (checked 2026-10-08)
  • Flask of the Titans: 10 Stonescale Oil
  • Elixir of Greater Defense (265): 2 Stonescale Oil
  • Greater Stoneshield Potion (280): 3 Stonescale Oil

Supply

  • Source: Fishing in Tanaris, Azshara, Feralas and Stranglethorn coasts, best at night
  • Competition: low
  • Level range: 45 to 60
  • Used by: Alchemy
  • Comes from: Fishing
  • Price: 1s 64c lowest buyout on PvP, scanned 2026-11-14
Phase Do Why
Launch week WATCH Out of reach.
Weeks 2 to 4 GATHER Fishers at 45 plus: bank them.
Raids open (December 9) and after SELL Tank consumables for raid night.

What would break this

  • Every use is client data above the beta skill cap of 225, on a route that changed between late September and 2026-10-08.
  • The Fishing Hut camp object catches rare fish hourly.

Evidence: foreverchanges.pro, foreverchanges.pro, wowhead.com, ahledger.com

HOLD, conviction 3 of 5. vanilla baseline Last changed 2026-10-08, see Rating changes.

Nightfin Soup and Grilled Squid were the standard healer and melee raid foods in vanilla. Checked 2026-10-08, the Forever client keeps both with different buffs: Nightfin Soup (Cooking 250) gives 22 spell damage and Grilled Squid (240) gives 1% critical strike, and Grilled Squid now needs an Iron Oven, a Cooking 300 camp object. The foreverchanges Cooking route no longer levels on them: it runs Filet of Redgill from 225 to 285. The guild plan wants three fishers at 300 partly for raid food. Forever adds stat foods across the whole skill range, so there may be better options.

Also covers: Winter Squid, Nightfin Soup, Grilled Squid.

Demand

  • Nightfin Soup (Cooking 250): 22 spell damage
  • Grilled Squid (Cooking 240, Iron Oven): 1% critical strike

Supply

  • Source: Fishing level 45 to 60 coasts; Nightfin at night, Winter Squid in the cold months
  • Competition: low
  • Level range: 45 to 60
  • Used by: Cooking
  • Comes from: Fishing
  • Price: 4s 46c lowest buyout on PvP, scanned 2026-11-14
Phase Do Why
Launch week WATCH Out of reach.
Weeks 2 to 4 GATHER Fishers bank them.
Raids open (December 9) and after USE Raid food every week.

What would break this

  • New Forever stat foods may replace both.
  • In vanilla, Winter Squid was seasonal. Not confirmed for Forever.
  • Grilled Squid needs an Iron Oven, which comes from a Blueprint.

Evidence: foreverchanges.pro, foreverchanges.pro, classicwowforever.com, wowhead.com

SELL EARLY, conviction 3 of 5. verified Last changed 2026-10-25, see Rating changes.

Blizzard confirmed that crafted food can grant a small experience bonus and stat boosts, and the client has stat foods across the whole skill range. Checked 2026-10-08, two fan sites that read the client (foreverchanges and classicwowforever) both show 5% more experience from kills while well fed. One of them gives it 15 minutes and notes the client shows that line only while a server setting is on, so it is not confirmed for launch. Blizzard has not published the number. If it holds, cooked food is a consumable every leveler wants, and cooks who level early can sell it for a month.

Also covers: Well Fed, Herb Baked Egg, Roasted Kodo Meat, Murloc Fin Soup, Goblin Deviled Clams.

Demand

  • Every leveling player, level 1 to 60
  • Cooking leveling itself

Supply

  • Source: Cooking from meat and fish; low-level meat is common
  • Competition: low
  • Level range: 1 to 60
  • Used by: Cooking
  • Comes from: Cooking
  • Guild: We can craft it. See the guild order book.
  • Price: no scan data yet
Phase Do Why
Launch week CRAFT Cook and sell stacks to levelers. Eat your own.
Weeks 2 to 4 CRAFT Still sells while the bulk of the server levels.
Raids open (December 9) and after SKIP Raiders want stat food, not XP food.

What would break this

  • The 5% figure is client data on two fan sites. One says it depends on a server setting, and Blizzard has not published the number.
  • Low-level meat is so common that anyone can cook their own.
  • Blizzard can still change the food experience bonus before launch, and campfire rest and the Cozy Sleeping Bag are other ways to level faster.
  • A Reddit beta professions census of 43,682 crafters reports that 88% of players had Cooking, so most levelers can cook their own food instead of buying it. Community report, not a Blizzard figure.

Evidence: worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com, classicwowforever.com, foreverchanges.pro, lfcarry.com, foreverchanges.pro