Skip to content

When the beta cap rose to 30, cloth fell by half in three days, but other materials did not

We asked what the beta auction house did after the level cap went up, and how fast material prices fell. At launch the cap will move again as raids and new content open, so it helps to know what kind of drop to expect and how long it lasts.

When the level cap goes up, players reach new zones and start gathering in them. The idea is that this floods the auction house with materials and prices drop. We wanted to know three things: did that happen in this beta, how fast, and did it last.

The beta cap went from 20 to 30 on 1 October. Our Roadmap page gives that date and cites Blizzard’s beta development notes updated on 1 October. Our price history starts on 21 September on PvP Horde and 22 September on PvP Alliance, so we have about ten days before the change and nearly three weeks after it.

A useful answer names which materials fell, by how much, how many days it took, and whether prices came back.

  • The cap went to level 30 on 1 October, and cloth fell fast: on PvP Horde a basket of 12 cloth items dropped 63.7% from 30 September to 3 October, and 10 of them fell by a quarter or more.
  • Cloth was the exception, not the rule: over the week to 7 October, Horde cloth ended 41.5% down, while herbs rose 3.8% and ore, bars and stone rose 29.3%.
  • The drop did not last: from 8 October to 19 October, full price scans show cloth back up 43.1% on PvP Horde and 52.4% on PvP Alliance. This is one cap change, so it is one example, not yet a rule.

We grouped trade goods by type: cloth, leather, herbs, ore, bars and stone, enchanting materials and cooking materials. For each group we built a basket index. A basket index takes each item’s price, divides it by that item’s own price on the starting day, and reports the middle value of the group. It starts at 100. So 50 means the typical item in the group costs half what it did on the starting day. This stops one expensive item from drowning out the rest.

We used 30 September, the last day before the cap rose, as the starting day, and compared it with 3 October and 7 October. All three days come from AHledger’s daily history, so they are measured the same way. Daily history covers about 250 to 320 items a day on each market, so each group holds only 5 to 22 items. We call a group thin when it has fewer than 10 items. To count how many cloth items “fell”, we used a drop of a quarter or more, because on quiet days a single item often moves 10 or 20% for no reason.

From 8 October on, the data comes from full price scans that cover every listed item. Those scans are not measured the same way as the daily history, so we never compare a day before 8 October with a day after it. The later chart starts a fresh basket on 8 October.

The single items we looked at most closely on PvP Horde, between 30 September and 3 October (our own reading of the daily medians):

  • Linen Cloth went from 1s 10c to 36c.
  • Wool Cloth went from 3s 21c to 88c.
  • Silk Cloth went from 15s 13c to 5s 49c, and kept falling to 2s 88c on 7 October.

Those three are the cheaper, lower level cloths, the kind players collect on the way to the cap. Higher cloth such as Mageweave and Runecloth jumped around with very few listings and showed no clear direction.

Line chart of the cloth basket index on both PvP markets from 21 September to 7 October, rising to about 125 before 1 October and falling to between 50 and 70 by 3 to 6 October

Each line is the cloth basket on one market, with the first day set to 100. Cloth was climbing in the last week of September. The day after the cap rose it began to fall, and by 3 October it was at about half its late September level on both markets. On PvP Alliance the cloth basket fell 46.1% from 30 September to 3 October, by our own calculation.

Bar chart of the change in each PvP Horde material group from 30 September to 7 October: cloth and cooking down by about 40%, enchanting slightly down, herbs flat, leather and ore up by about a third

Each bar is one group of materials over the first week after the cap rose. Only cloth and cooking fell hard, and cooking holds just 5 items, so it is too thin to trust. Leather and ore went up, not down.

Bar chart of the same week on PvP Alliance: cloth down by about 45%, cooking down, leather, herbs and ore all up

The same week on PvP Alliance tells the same story. Cloth fell. Herbs, leather and ore went up. Leather on both markets has fewer than 12 items, so its rise rests on a handful of listings.

Line chart of the cloth basket from 8 to 19 October on both PvP markets, flat for a week and then rising to between 140 and 155

This basket starts again at 100 on 8 October and holds 18 cloth items, including threads. It stayed flat for about a week and then rose from 15 October onward. Do not join it to the first chart: the two are measured differently.

So the honest answer to “how fast do materials fall after the cap rises” is: in this beta, cloth fell within two to three days, hit bottom within a week, and was climbing again by the third week. Most other materials did not fall at all. We cannot say the cap rise caused the cloth drop. The timing fits, but the data cannot rule out other causes, such as a new beta build or more players logging in that week. You can follow cloth prices day by day on The Terminal and Charts.

  • A second cap rise. If launch content opens new zones and cloth again drops by a third or more within three days, while herbs and ore hold, the pattern gets much stronger. If cloth holds steady after the next rise, the October drop was probably something else.
  • Sold-a-day figures around a cap change. The daily history before 8 October has no sales estimate, so we cannot tell if cloth fell because more was listed or because fewer people bought it. Full scans across the next cap change would show that.
  • Larger groups. Most material groups here hold 10 to 22 items. If later data with every item priced showed herbs or ore falling after a cap change, the second bullet would no longer hold.
  • A known cause. If a beta build note from late September or early October changed cloth drops, vendor prices or tailoring recipes, that would explain the drop without the cap.
  • One example. The beta has had one cap change in our history. One event cannot tell you a speed you can count on.
  • Level 30 cap, no raids. Demand for high cloth, herbs and ore comes from level 60 crafting and raiding. None of that exists in the beta, so the launch market will behave differently.
  • Small population. A few players listing or buying can move a whole group.
  • The wipe. Everything is deleted before launch on November 4. Nothing here is advice to hold anything. The only thing that carries over is the order of things: cloth from new zones looked like the first material to drop, not by how much.
  • Two kinds of data. Before 8 October every price is AHledger’s daily history of about 320 items a market. From 8 October it is full scans of every item. A jump between 7 and 8 October can come from that change alone, so we never measured across it.
  • Estimates. Sold-a-day figures are estimates and exist only in the newest scan, so this report does not use them.